The term “The President’s Cabinet” was coined by James Madison, father of the Constitution, when referring to George Washington’s top advisors. The first cabinet of the US had only four members: Secretary of State Thomas Jefferson, Secretary of the Treasury Alexander Hamilton, Secretary of War Henry Knox, and Attorney General Edmund Randolph. Currently, presidential cabinets are 16 people, usually the heads of the executive departments and the Attorney General of the United States.
Article II, Sec 2 of the Constitution stipulates that the President’s nominees receive the advice and consent of the Senate; 2/3 of the Senate must vote yea for confirmation. Confirmation hearings give Senators a chance to examine the qualifications of each nominee and ask questions. Senate rules were changed after The Civil War to first require Senate committees review and interview nominees before a full Senate confirmation hearing goes forward. Most nominees are confirmed. You can see a list of those who were not on the Senate’s webpage here.
President Trump announced his cabinet picks in November of 2024. He threatened to make recess appointments if the Senate did not move quickly to confirm his top picks. The Constitution allows presidents to make ‘recess appointments’ if the Senate cannot meet, though these were meant as an emergency measure as clarified in the 2014 Supreme Court ruling National Labor Relations Board v Noel Canning.
Over the past few weeks, The Senate has confirmed a handful of nominations and is continuing to hold hearings for the remaining nominations. The rest of the President’s picks appear on track for approval, though not without controversy.
The resources below examine the historical trends in cabinet nominations and Senate hearings, as well as recent news coverage of the review of President Trumps nominations. There are also educational materials on the Executive Branch and the departments within. Civics Learning Project’s Senate Cabinet Confirmation Hearing lesson plan gives students a chance to form their own opinion as to the suitability of the person for the job, and give a speech recommending a yea or nay vote to the rest of the Senate.
Essential Questions:
- What is the form and function of a Presidential cabinet?
- How have Presidential cabinets changed over time?
- Who are President Trump’s nominees for his second term?
- How are the Senate confirmation hearings going for Trump’s nominees?
- What are your thoughts about his picks?
Vocabulary:
- President’s Cabinet: the team of people who advise the President on all important problems they must face and lead the departments for the Executive Branch of our government
- Executive Departments: The fifteen executive departments that carry out the day-to-day administration of the federal government
- vetting process: a thorough investigation of a person, company, or other entity to determine if they are suitable for a particular role or action
- recess appointment: presidents have limited powers to make temporary appointments when the Senate is not in session
Videos:
The Origin of the President’s Cabinet, The White House Historical Association
What to expect during confirmation hearings for Trump’s cabinet picks, Campaign Legal Center, Jan 15, 2025
Breaking down day 3 of Senate confirmation hearings for Trump’s Cabinet nominees, CBSNews, Jan 16, 2025
Podcasts:
- Putty people: can Trump get his picks? The Economist, Jan 30, 2025 (2 min in – 11 min mark)
- Kash Patel faces questions in FBI director confirmation hearing, Here & Now, Jan 30, 2025
- RFK Jr.’s Controversial Senate Hearings Begin, Wisconsin Afternoon News, Jan 29, 2025
Background Resources:
- VIDEO: What Is the Executive Branch of the U.S. Government? The History Channel
- Cabinet Members, George Washington’s Mount Vernon
- About Executive Nominations, The US Senate
- Cabinet Nominations Rejected, Withdrawn, or No Action Taken, The US Senate
- Political Appointee Tracker, Partnership for Public Service, Live Updates
- What Americans think about Hegseth, Gabbard and key Trump Cabinet picks: AP-NORC poll, AP, Dec 13, 2024
Recent Articles:
- Who has joined Trump’s top team? BBC, Jan 20, 2025
- White House warns of ‘consequences’ for Republicans who don’t support all of Trump’s nominees, NBC News, Jan 26, 2025
- Senate advances Hegseth nomination; Collins, Murkowski vote ‘no’, The Hill, Jan 23, 2025
- Trump’s Cabinet picks are set for Senate hearings. Here’s the schedule, AP, Jan 24, 2025
- Here’s a look at the busy week ahead for Trump’s Cabinet nominees, Government Executive, Jan 27, 2025
- Robert F. Kennedy Jr. struggles to answer questions on Medicare and Medicaid at confirmation hearing, News 6+ (Orlando, FL), Jan 29, 2025
- RFK Jr. faces questions on past anti-vaccine statements, abortion in confirmation hearing to be HHS secretary, CBS News, Jan 29, 2025
- Tracking Trump cabinet confirmations – so far, The Guardian, Jan 28, 2025
Recent Editorials:
- Trump’s Cabinet picks boast thin resumes. That’s the point: ANALYSIS, ABC News, Nov 22, 2024
- Marsha Blackburn: Trump assembled a dream team Cabinet. Confirm them all. The Tennessean, Jan 22, 2025
- Trump’s Cabinet Picks Prepare for the Lowlight, Bloomberg, Jan 13, 2025
Lesson Plans:
- Senate Cabinet Confirmation Hearings: Writing and Delivering a Persuasive Speech, Civics Learning Project
- Cabinet Building, iCivics
- Lesson Plan: The Role of Executive Departments, CSPAN Classroom
Resources for Younger Students:
- Government Mini Lesson – The Executive Branch, SUNY Open Access Repository
- Executive Branch, Center for Civic Education (elementary)
- Executive Branch, Center for Civic Education (middle)